Carnegie Mellon Libraries: Services: Tutorials: Web Evaluation

Web Evaluation

The free web provides a variety of information, not all of which is suitable for academic research.

This tutorial is designed to point out what to look for when gathering information that is valuable for research.

Examples of good web sites are provided, along with some examples of bad sources.


 
Why is this important?
Web sites may be sloppy or even misleading... Anyone can publish on the web. Find out who wrote it... Information is rarely neutral... Don't be satisfied with the short and superficial... Web information may be out of date...

How to evaluate it

Statements should be supported by logic and evidence...

Look for author and publisher credentials...

Think about the goal of the site...

Is the topic covered adequately?...

Be aware of dates, how to find them, and what they mean....


Examples

 

 

 

 

 

 


Gender Differences

"Gone with the Wind"

Molecules

Robots

Shotgun House

Tecumseh


American West

Artist William Rimmer

Greenhouse Effect

Herb Simon

Mary Queen of Scots

Tourette Syndrome

 


Bullfight in Spain

China

Depression

Human Rights

Low Carb Diet

Nutrition: Meat


Accounting Standards

Conformity

Korea

News

Periodic Table

Walt Whitman

 


African History

Animal Rights

Census Pennsylvania

Child Development

Law and Economics

Opinion Poll








































This tutorial was created by Jean Alexander, Diane Covington and Kati Koch.


  Contact Us | Site Map | Comments

  August 4, 2004 -- http://www.library.cmu.edu/Services/Tutorials/WebEval/index.html
  Jean Alexander, Head of Hunt Reference, jeana@andrew.cmu.edu
  © 2004 Carnegie Mellon Libraries